Mrs. Hemingway by Naomi Wood
by
Natasa Djordjevic
- 1:04 AM
“But writers and their woes: they couldn't be parted. Not for anything.”
The writing initially transported me to the elegant world of French pastry—delightful and indulgent, each sentence a sweet, soft treat that pleases the palate and is pleasing to the eye. As the narrative deepens, however, it evolves into something grittier and more raw, reflecting the complex personalities and tumultuous circumstances of Ernest Hemingway and his wives. Naomi Wood, with her remarkable talent, skillfully weaves together a rich tapestry of complexity, history, and emotional depth, making this book easily one of the most engaging and thought-provoking reads I’ve encountered in quite some time.
Wood expertly chronicles the lives of four distinct women over the course of 40 years, each bearing her own extraordinary story. I was particularly struck by the structural choice to allocate exactly one-fourth of the book to each woman’s narrative, a detail that the writer in me found not only intriguing but also a testament to Wood’s careful planning. The timeline largely follows a chronological path, anchored firmly by the individual stories of these women. Yet, I was captivated by Wood’s skillful navigation through time, as she artfully jumps back and forth through the years, creating a rich and coherent tapestry that connects their lives.
The journey begins with Hadley, the first of Hemingway's wives, whose experience unfolds with a bittersweet sweetness. Following her story, we meet Fife, who enters with her own set of complexities and struggles, revealing the personal sacrifices made within the confines of her relationship. Next comes Martha G., whose vibrant spirit offers a refreshing contrast to her predecessors, bringing moments of light amidst the shadows. Finally, we arrive at Mary, whose tale brings us to the final chapters of Hemingway’s life, marked by somber reflections and lingering questions. I must admit, however, that I found an overwhelming sense of sadness permeating their stories, with the exception of Martha, whose resilience stood out as a beacon of hope. This feeling of melancholy made it difficult for me to connect with them, as they seemed worlds away from the vibrant, empowered women I admire in my own life.
In truth, it was alarmingly easy to view these four women merely as Hemingway's wives, defined by their relationships with him rather than as distinct individuals with their own dreams and passions—Martha being the notable exception who shone brightly as an entity in her own right. This tendency to frame them through the lens of Hemingway’s larger-than-life persona significantly colored my perception of their identities. The author’s focus on their lives primarily in relation to him left me yearning for a deeper exploration of their individual stories.
As I immersed myself in the narrative, I couldn’t escape my growing aversion to Hemingway himself. I found myself judging all of them harshly, critiquing their choices and their entanglements with such a complicated figure. Yet, as I delved deeper into his life and learned about the eventual outcomes for each character, a powerful feeling of sympathy washed over me—not just for him, but for Hadley, Fife, Martha, and Mary as well. By the end of the book, I was left with the sobering realization that Ernest was the one who truly seemed to bear the weight of profound sorrow, navigating through a lifetime of emotional turmoil, overshadowed by his own creative genius and the complexities of his relationships. This revelation transformed my understanding of these women into something much more nuanced and multi-layered, highlighting the intersections of love, loss, and resilience that defined their lives alongside his
